HISTORY OF CIVIL-MILITARY RELATIONS IN NIGERIA (Part 3)*

COUNT-DOWN TO THE JANUARY 1966 COUP

In the Nigerian Army's official history of the Civil War, Major General IBM
Haruna (rtd), said:  "The dominance of the NPC and the perceived dominance
of the North in the centre were like a threat to the presumed more
enlightened and better educated Southerners who believed they were the
backbone of the movement for Nigerian independence but did not succeed the
colonial power to run the affairs of the state.  So with that background one
can now lay the foundation of the perception of the military struggle in
Nigerian politics."

Reflective, therefore, of certain repeatedly articulated viewpoints in
sections of the Press, the opinion matured among a small budding caucus of
already politically inclined officers after independence, that every
military deployment for internal security in aid of the civil authority
whose political orientation they did not share, even if constitutional, was
just another provocation.    These include:

1. 'Operation Banker', a joint Army-Police operation in the Western region,
led by then CO, 4th battalion, Lt. Col. Maimalari, allegedly at the behest
of the pro-NPC regional Premier (Akintola) culminating in the declaration of
a state of emergency in May 1962 after a fracas in the House of Assembly and
the appointment of an administrator.    Interestingly, the General Staff
Officer (2) at the Army HQ in charge of Intelligence was none other than
Captain Patrick Chukwuma Nzeogwu who, as a Major, was later to play a key
role in the coup of January 1966 in which Maimalari lost his life.

2. The arrest on September 22, 1962 and subsequent imprisonment of the
opposition leader, Chief Awolowo, on suspicion of planning a civilian
overthrow of the government.  It was alleged that 300 volunteers were sent
to Ghana for 3 weeks militia training.  Certain accounts hypothesize two
separate plots, one by Dr. Maja and the other by Awo himself.  But there is
a body of evidence that indicates that Dr. Maja was actually collaborating
with the government.  The real plotters planned to exploit the absence from
the country of three out of the five Army battalions to seize key points in
Lagos and arrest leading figures of the government. The absent battalions
were in or on their way to and from the Congo.  One available military
detachment at Abeokuta was out on military training exercises, while the
newly formed federal guard in Lagos was essentially ceremonial.  Thus, there
was an internal security vacuum which the plotters intended to exploit.
Court records also indicate that an attempt was made to recruit Brigadier
Adesoji Ademulegun for the scheme but he refused to cooperate with the
plotters, choosing instead to remain loyal to the traditional military
hierarchy and government, which had just promoted him from Lt. Col. to
Brigadier. Whether this later played a role in his subsequent assassination
in January 1966 is unknown.

3. Army Stand-by during the acrimonious reactions to the National Census of
1962/63 and 1963/64.

4. Army Stand-by during the Midwest referendum of 1963.

5. Mobilization of the Army to provide essential services during the General
Strike of 1964.  Even this apparently innocuous deployment in support of the
civil authority attracted criticism from some of the would-be plotters of
the January 1966 coup.  Captain Nwobosi (rtd), for example, has said that as
a young officer deployed to the railways as an escort, he was troubled by
the fact that the Prime Minister left Lagos for his home town in Bauchi
during the strike, leaving crucial matters of state to assistants in Lagos
as well as the Army which was fully mobilized.  I have not been able to
independently verify the validity of this accusation against Balewa, but it
does provide insights into the expectations of soldiers of their civilian
masters when they are drafted by civil authorities to stabilize the polity.
A perception of lack of a "hands on" approach, even if false, can undermine
authority and the culture of respect.

6. Tiv Crises:  As far back as April 1960 and July 1961 the Army had been
placed on standby in Tiv land.  This became necessary again in February
1964.  However, on November 18, 1964 the 3rd battalion under Lt. Col James
Pam which was just returning from Tanzania was deployed in full for internal
security operations there.  The choice of Pam's unit was a deft move because
he was of middle belt origin and the battalion had been out of the country
training another Army, and thus insulated from acrimony.  The Nigerian Army
actually emerged from this operation with high marks because the local
people saw Pam's unit as more neutral than the Mobile Police. Interestingly,
Major Anuforo of the Recce unit at Kaduna was deployed in support of Pam for
this operation.  This is the officer who later shot him during the January
1966 coup.   Other would-be plotters who served in Tiv land were Ademoyega
and Onwatuegwu.

7. Constitutional crisis of January 1965: Following the controversial
Federal Election of December 1964, ceremonial President Azikiwe of the NCNC,
urged by radical intelligentsia, refused to invite Prime Minister Balewa of
the NPC to form a government and issued orders mobilizing the Army to
enforce his authority to suspend the government, annul the elections and
appoint a temporary interim administrator to conduct elections.  However,
the oath of allegiance of the officer corps was not only to the Commander in
Chief but also to the government of Nigeria. The Army Act (#26 of 1960) and
the Navy Act (#9 of 1960) were also clear on lines of authority and control.
While the Army and Navy were "under the general authority" of the Defence
Minister in matters of "command, discipline and administration", the
authority for operational use and control was vested in the Council of
Ministers and the Prime Minister.  President Azikiwe and the service chiefs
were so advised by the Chief Justice and Attorney General of the Federation.
Thus the Navy Commander, Commodore Wey politely told the President that the
Navy (under him), the Army (under Major General Welby-Everard) and the
Police (under Louis Edet) had decided to refuse his orders.   After a week
of cliff hanging tension, in which the military stood aside, a political
compromise was eventually reached and a government of "national unity"
formed under Prime Minister Balewa.  In the US Diplomatic Archives: Nigeria
1964-1968, the situation was characterized in this manner:  "Very
complicated African politics, in which tribes, religions and economics all
play a part, are involved in the situation. The Northern Premier is at odds
with the Eastern Premier in whose region large oil deposits have been
discovered. In the heat of the election campaign, there have been threats of
secession by the east; threats of violence "that would make Congo look like
child's play" from the north.."  At the same time, strong rumors of an
impending Army coup purportedly planned for the annual Army Shooting
competition were also heard in political circles.  But the status quo held,
albeit temporarily.

8. Army Stand by during the ethnic leadership crisis between Yorubas and
Igbos at the University of Lagos in March 1965.

9. Army Stand-by during the Western regional Election of October 1965 which
led to a break down of law and order.  Political pressures and recrimination
resulting from this exposure finally cracked the façade of political
neutrality among some officers exposing deep personal, ethnic, regional and
political schisms in the process.  To quote Captain Nwobosi again, "When I
was in Abeokuta, my soldiers were being detailed to go somewhere towards
Lagos from Abeokuta to guard ballot boxes that were not opened.  They were
not opened but somebody had already been declared the winner.  Everyday,
they would go and come back and in the process, I lost one of my corporals.
You know soldiers are soldiers and sometimes like children, you have your
favourite ones and this was personal."

10. A subsequent alleged plan to bring the situation in the West under
control by the NPC controlled federal government in support of its regional
ally, using the Army as had been done in 1962, allegedly brought forward the
date of the January 15 coup.  The coup was organized by predominantly
Eastern officers sympathetic to the UPGA alliance of political parties that
had lost the 1964 federal elections and the October 1965 regional elections
in the West.  The majority of casualties were Northern politicians and
senior military officers from the same alma mater all of whom were deemed to
represent the NPC or its interests. Others were politicians and officers
from the western region viewed as being in alliance with the NPC leadership.
The coup failed to bring the "young turks" who led it to power but it did
result, through a complex and controversial series of events, in the
emergence of a military regime led by General Ironsi.

There is a tragic post-script to the widely held (but false) presumption
that the January 15 coup pre-empted an inevitable military operation to
crack down in the West.   This presumption is based on a reported meeting
between key NPC and NNDP political leaders as well as certain senior
military officers said to have occurred in Kaduna on January 14.   However,
the last interview granted to the magazine 'West Africa', by the late Prime
Minister Balewa on January 14, a few hours to his death, went like this:

"Question:  Do you see the solution as taking the form of a coalition
government in the West?

Balewa:  Yes, it would have to be that ...The Action group has accepted my
mediation, but the NNDP has asked for more time.If I use real force in the
West - and make no mistake about it, I haven't yet - then I could bring the
people to their knees.  But I don't want to use force like that.  Force can'
t bring peace to people's hearts.

Question:  Would you consider the release of Chief Awolowo as part of a
political solution of the West's troubles?

Balewa:  I think that might be part of it; yes, obviously we would have to
see."

This interview was not published until January 29, 1966.

CIVIL-MILITARY INSTITUTIONAL RELATIONSHIPS BEFORE 1966

Until the coup of 1966, civil-military relations after independence
basically followed the classic model.  Soldiers were rarely seen in public
in their uniforms unless there was an official event.  Barracks were mostly
separated and remote from concentrations of civilian housing.  Political
speech making, writing articles in the lay press without approval, or
political campaigns in barracks by or at the behest of soldiers were not
allowed.  Furthermore, in part because there was no significant external
threat, but also because of the predominance of British officers at the top
until 1965, the army command played very little role in security policy
making.  The major foreign policy decisions of that era were made by the
political class.  Even in its internal security role the Army did not make
policy. It carried them out.

However, the socialization process that made this relationship possible
seemed to be confined to the uppermost echelons of the military where
officers who had spent the longest amount of time working directly with
British officers before independence were to be found.  Coincidentally,
certain key officers at these levels shared certain social origins with key
political leaders.  Officers at lower and middle rungs of the ladder,
however, did not share many of those attributes because the transition from
decolonization to democratization was rushed, driven by notions of
patriotism.

From October 1st 1960 until May 1st 1965 when he died naturally of an
illness Alhaji Muhammadu Ribadu, the second Vice President of the Northern
Peoples Congress, served as Minister for Defence.  From May 1965 until
January 1966 his place was taken by Alhaji Inua Wada, also a member of the
NPC.  They were both civilians with no prior military service.  Ribadu (also
known as "Power of Powers") was a very influential and highly regarded
politician with extensive connections across the political divide.  His
sudden death in April 1965 is said by some to have seriously undermined the
reconciliation of the frayed political relationship between the NPC and the
NCNC after the January 1965 crisis which may have prevented the January 1966
coup.  Indeed, active plotting for coup actually began after his death that
year.

Ribadu presided over a rapid expansion of the Army and Navy as well as the
creation of the Nigerian Air Force.  The establishment of the Defence
Industries Corporation, the Nigerian Defence Academy, a second Recce
Squadron (located at Abeokuta) and two new Artillery batteries occurred on
his watch.  He got practically all his budgetary requests through parliament
including approval to spend 19.5 million pounds on defence from 1962-66 as
compared with 5.5 million pounds during the preceding seven year period.
Defence costs as a percentage of Federal recurrent spending from 1958-1966
ranged from 7.7 to 9.9%.  Defence costs as a percentage of Federal capital
spending during the same period ranged from 1.5 to 12.1%.

Pressure to expand the military did not originate from within the military.
It came from the political class.  Resistance to additional defence spending
did not come from the legislature or the public.  It originated in 1962 and
1964 from other Ministers as well as economists in the Ministry of Finance
concerned about failure to meet national economic targets.  Ribadu lost the
Chairmanship of the Economic Committee of the federal cabinet in 1964, a
position he had used skillfully to protect and oversee his defence
appropriations.  Thus civilian oversight of military budgeting in the first
republic was total and exclusive.  In my opinion, the late Alhaji Muhammadu
Ribadu is probably Nigeria's best Defence Minister since Independence - a
point that belies the tendency these days to think that civilians with no
military experience cannot run the Ministry of Defence.

In addition to Ribadu there were Ministers of State for the Army and Navy.
From February 1960 until August 1961 Dr. Majekodunmi, a physician, was the
Minister of State for the Army.  Then Jacob Obande held the position from
August 1961 until December 1962.  From January 1963 until January 1966 the
position was held by Ibrahim Tako Galadima - a personality (unlike Ribadu)
whose grasp of military affairs and protocol was not respected within the
military.   Mr. M. T. Mbu was Minister of State for the Navy from 1960 to
1966.   Mr. AA Atta was the permanent secretary from 1960-64 while Alhaji
Sule Kolo held the position from 1964-66.  Like the substantive ministers of
that era, both were northerners.

One area in which there was direct political interference from the political
class as a group in military professional policy was in the question of
quotas for Army recruitment, which nevertheless reflected legislative
pressures in a multiethnic society.  Such political pressures to apply the
federal character principle have found their way into subsequent Nigerian
constitutions.    Other than one or two alleged cases, politicians generally
stayed out of purely military professional matters.  Even when the departing
GOC General Welby-Everard, (for a variety of reasons dating back to events
in 1951 and 1961), recommended either Brigadier Ademulegun or Ogundipe as
his successor, the Prime Minister and the Defence Minister chose to stick
with the principle of seniority and chose Ironsi instead - perhaps mindful
of NCNC sensitivities coming as it did, after the constitutional crisis in
January and around the time of the acrimonious fight over the Vice
Chancellorship of the University of Lagos.    The literature reports that
Brigadier Ademulegun lobbied for the position of GOC through his friend the
Sardauna, but it would seem that the political leadership of the Ministry
resisted all such pressures.   Until just before the collapse, therefore,
the link between the Army leadership and the political class was mostly
formal and appropriate. Although informal liaisons existed on the basis of
alma mater and other shared values, these did not rise to the level of the
client networks (such as "IBB Boys" or "Abacha Boys")  that came to
characterize future military regimes in the country.   Nevertheless, in a
country where ethnic identities were and are often stronger than
professional identities, any perceived coincidences of  liaisons with the
ethnic, political and security map of the country were bound to provoke
suspicion among officers who considered themselves outside those networks.

The final intervention of predominantly eastern junior and middle ranking
military officers resulted from the gradual decline in the cohesion and
legitimacy of civilian institutions, signs of which were already evident
from the time of the December 1959 federal elections before independence.
Certain long standing colonial military policies, amplified by the fractious
nature of Nigeria's political framework set against Nigeria's unique history
provided a backdrop to contentious civil military relations after
independence.  As the role of the independent army evolved from external
missions and its participation in internal security deepened, political
antagonisms toward elements of the political class were amplified as it
found itself making judgments and allocating values.  Latent societal
cleavages began to undermine esprit d'Corps.  It was from among those who
enlisted between 1957 (when the FDC took over from the British Army council
and introduced quotas into the rank and file) and 1961 (when quotas were
introduced into the officer corps) that the deepest schisms appeared,
enabled by other political undercurrents in larger society.   As the Roman
military writer, Vegetius (De Re Militari), wrote in 378 B.C.:  'An army
raised without proper regard to the choice of its recruits was never made
good by length of time.'

In the final analysis, driven by bitter fights for political control, lack
of unity in the civil class between the coalition partners, NCNC and NPC,
along with disenfranchisement of some stake-holders in the Action Group (who
continued to be loyal to the jailed Chief Awolowo) played a crucial role in
undermining whatever organized resistance (with or without British help) the
political class might have put up to save democracy when some soldiers came
calling in January 1966.  Indeed, military intervention may have been sought
by aggrieved elements of the political class.  As the Police Special Branch
report put it:  "..sometime during August 1965, a small group of army
officers, dissatisfied with political developments within the federation,
began to plot in collaboration with some civilians, the overthrow of what
was then the Government of the Federation of Nigeria."
[http://www.gamji.com/NEWS1103.htm]   Fearful of certain anticipated
political decisions which might have involved the use of the Army to
forcefully restore order in the Akintola-led Western region and cram the
results of the controversial October 1965 election down the throats of
voters, the coup was finally launched on January 15, 1966.   But as I have
noted previously, the paradox about this alleged NPC plan to "wallop" the
West is that the late Prime Minister, Tafawa Balewa, in his last interview
just before the coup was actually contemplating a political solution to the
impasse in the Western region, one that might even have involved a coalition
government and the release of Chief Obafemi Awolowo from jail.  At the final
meeting just before H-hour in Major Ifeajuna's house in Lagos, the Police
report says "Major Ifeajuna addressed the meeting on the subject of the
deteriorating situation in Western Nigeria to which, he contended, the
politicians had failed to find a solution.  He added that as a result the
entire country was heading toward chaos and disaster".

One of the key participants in the coup, Captain Emmanuel Nwobosi has also
recently expressed the opinion that there was "information" that the NPC
dominated Federal Government would declare a state of emergency in the NCNC
dominated Eastern region in coordination with an agitation for the creation
of Rivers state.  In the Army's Official history of the Civil War, Nwobosi
said:  "Adaka Boro was stationed in the Rivers area to start off some
insurrection and the East would have been declared an area under a state of
emergency like was done in the West under Dr. Majekodunmi."  Nwobosi also
said that this information "is not something you will hear and go to sleep".
Such perceptions - some of which were plainly false -  among officers with
sympathies for (or views coincident with) the United Progressive Grand
Alliance, set against the NPC-NCNC-Army constitutional crisis of January
1965 and the background tensions inherited at independence, provided fuel
for the events of January 1966.  Captain Emmanuel Nwobosi (rtd) who led
operations in the West during the coup, holds the opinion that President
Nnamdi Azikiwe was briefed about the coup plot by Major Emmanuel Ifeajuna in
Lagos - but points out that his own sub-group was not in on Ifeajuna's
duplicity.  He has also said that one of the intentions of the plotters was
to release Chief Awolowo from jail - a somewhat strangely coincident plan to
what Prime Minister Balewa was contemplating before he was killed.

In the state of confusion that reigned after the Prime Minister's abduction
on January 15, refusal of the President of the Senate (Nwafor Orizu, an
easterner from the NCNC - who was also acting President) to accept the
appointment by the NPC dominated cabinet of an interim Prime Minister
(Dipcharima, a northerner) closed whatever option remained to formally
invite British Troops in (with or without a pact).  With no constitutional
provision for such a move, Orizu and the rump cabinet chose to "hand over"
to the Army Chief, Major Gen Ironsi, (himself an easterner) allegedly to
give him needed authority to put down the coup attempt which had already
collapsed in the south.

It appears from testimony provided by former President Shagari that the
British would likely have responded to an invitation from Acting Prime
Minister Dipcharima in the same way as they did in East Africa two years
earlier.  Indeed, other sources claim that a British Battalion was already
on standby.  Interestingly, recently declassified American State department
archives also show that American intervention was also contemplated in
Nigerian government circles before the rump cabinet was advised to "hand
over" to General Ironsi to "avoid disaster".  Along with the brutal and
regionally asymmetric murders that accompanied the coup, this fateful
decision, which Orizu later defended as "patriotic", ushered in a very
bloody chapter in Nigerian history.   However, surviving officers of the
January 15 plot (like Nwobosi and Ademoyega) seem united in their belief
that it was General Ironsi's 'misrule', rather than their unfortunate
actions that night, that led Nigeria to chaos in the months ahead.